10 Essential Questions to Ask Your Wedding Cake Maker With Expert Insights From Lily at The Imaginary Bakery
Your wedding cake is more than just dessert, it’s a centrepiece, a photo moment, and a chance to express your style (and taste)! Before you book your wedding cake maker, make sure you’re asking the right questions to avoid any surprises later.
We recently had the pleasure of chatting all things cake with Cornwall’s queen of vintage piping, Lily from The Imaginary Bakery. With nearly four years in the wedding industry, Lily is renowned for her retro-inspired designs and intricate piped detail, the kind that turns a three tier wedding cake into a show stopping piece of edible art.
Drawing on Lily’s expertise, we’ve put together 10 essential questions every couple should ask their cake maker when planning the perfect wedding cake in Cornwall.
1. How far in advance should I book my wedding cake?
Wedding cake makers can get booked up. Good cake makers are in high demand, especially during the summer wedding season in Cornwall.
Lily recommends booking early: “Ideally, 9 months or more, key dates do get booked up quickly. Once your date is secured with a deposit, we can explore additional extras later.”
2. How much will it cost, and are there any hidden or extra charges?
Get a clear idea of what’s included in the quote. Some cake makers charge extra for things like intricate designs, delivery or premium flavours, so it’s worth asking for a full breakdown.
Lily says “A three tier wedding cake (80 portions) usually ranges from £500 to £700, depending on the level of detail and flavour choices.”
3. Can I have multiple flavours in one cake?
Absolutely! Mixing flavours across tiers is a popular option and allows you to offer variety for guests.
“I always advise couples to go for this! Choose your favourite flavour for the top tier so you can take it home after the wedding. It’s a lovely way to cover all flavour bases.”
A multi-flavoured wedding cake gives guests a taste of everything and makes the cake cutting even more exciting.
4. Is there a delivery and setup fee?
Don’t forget the logistics. Some cake makers include delivery and setup in their pricing, others charge separately. Ask whether delivery to your venue is available and if setup is part of the service.
“Yes, all of this is costed based on venue location (mileage/hourly). Setup is always included. I also offer collection for mini-tier cakes. Transparency with costs is super important.”
Whether your wedding is tucked away on a Cornish cliff or in a rustic barn, ensure delivery is stress free.
5. Do you provide a cake stand and knife?
It’s often an overlooked detail, but many cake makers will supply a stand and knife for the day — sometimes for an added fee or refundable deposit. If not, you’ll need to arrange one with your venue or stylist.
“I don’t provide these but definitely ask your venue if they supply a stand and knife or check with your stylist or décor hire company.”
If you're planning a vintage piping wedding cake Cornwall moment, the right stand can really enhance the overall look.
6. Will I receive a sketch or visual of the design?
A sketch or design board helps you visualise the result and ensure you're both on the same page. Some cake makers include this in the process; others might charge for design visuals.
“Yes, I always include a hand-drawn sketch alongside the quote. It’s such a helpful tool. Revisions can be made and if the design changes, I’ll provide a new sketch. The process starts with a colour palette and inspiration image and evolves into a fully bespoke design.”
7. When do I need to confirm the final design?
Cake designs often evolve especially if you’re still finalising colours or flowers. Ask when they’ll need the final design signed off, so you can stay on track.
“Six weeks before the wedding is ideal. Last-minute requests can happen, and I’ll always do my best to accommodate. I aim for all couple to have a stress-free journey.”
8. Can I try a sample of the flavours?
Tastings are one of the best parts of cake planning! Check if flavour samples are included, if they’re in-person or postal, and whether there’s a fee (some cake makers deduct this if you book).
Lily does offer tastings: “Yes, I offer postal cake tasting boxes, and in-person consultations at my home with four flavours. I also offer local cupcake box collections.”
Trying before you buy is a must for any wedding cake maker in Cornwall worth their buttercream!
9. What portion size is the cake designed for?
Cakes are often designed based on portion size (coffee vs dessert portions). Your cake maker can advise what size cake you’ll need based on your guest count and how it will be served.
“My website has guidance for sizing. I always allow for a good-sized slice of cake — it’s a celebration, after all! I also provide a cutting guide (2" x 1") so couples can pass it on to their caterer or venue.”
Ensuring your wedding cake is the right size prevents any last-minute dessert dramas.
10. How do you cater for dietary requirements?
Whether it’s gluten-free, dairy-free or vegan options, ask how your cake maker handles dietary needs. They may be able to offer alternative tiers or mini cakes to suit everyone.
“All dietary requirements are discussed during the final consultation. I’m also working on some delicious vegan and gluten-free options for 2026. Watch this space!”
More couples are requesting inclusive options for their Cornwall wedding cake, and Lily is ready to adapt.
Other Top Tips from Lily
Where will the cake be displayed?
“Don’t hide it in a corner! It’s the most romantic and expensive cake you’ll ever buy. Make it an event. My own cake will be on a vintage dessert trolley when I get married this August!”
Make your Cornwall wedding cake moment a true visual showstopper.
Cutting the cake? Lily says:
“Cut from the bottom tier, face the photographer, and don’t block each other. Listen to your photographer for the best angle!”
Final Thoughts
Booking your wedding cake maker in Cornwall is one of the sweetest parts of the planning journey but asking the right questions makes it even smoother. Whether you're dreaming of a whimsical vintage piping wedding cake or a sleek modern design, these tips will help you feel confident at your consultation.
Want to find the best cake makers in Cornwall?
Check out our Supplier Spotlights on Instagram for trusted local bakers who’ll bring your cake dreams to life or head over to the Cakes section on our website to browse our handpicked selection of Cornwall’s finest cake makers.
Credits:
Photo 1: Supplier: The Imaginary Bakery | Photographer: Lyra & Moth Photography
Photo 2: Supplier: The Imaginary Bakery | Photographer: Sophie Veres Photography
Photo 3: Supplier: White Peony Cake Company | Photographer: Desert Rose | Venue: Camel Studio
Photo 4: Supplier: Ausel Cakes
Photo 5: Supplier: The Imaginary Bakery | Photographer: Matt Wing Photo | Venue: The Barn at Pengelly
Photo 6: Supplier: Amber Cake Design
Photo 7: Supplier: The Imaginary Bakery | Photographer: Laab Photography
Photo 8: Supplier: Ausel Cakes
Photo 9: Supplier: Ausel Cakes
Photo 10: Supplier: Ausel Cakes
Photo 11: Supplier: Amber Cake Design | Venue: The Barn at Avington
